当前小额诉讼程序主客观相结合的适用条件,使部分本不应适用小额诉讼程序的案件以该程序结案,产生了一些问题。本文通过分析小额诉讼程序的各个环节状况,探讨当前适用条件所体现的核心问题——侵害了当事人程序选择权。通过分析其适用条件以及与域外法系相关制度、其他程序相关制度等两方面横向对比,结合简易程序已不能适应实际需要的现实困境,分析小额诉讼程序对满足人民群众高效司法需求的重要作用,明确小额诉讼程序的独立价值——为当事人提供一种高效的程序选择。从尊重当事人程序选择权角度,建议完善小额诉讼程序的适用条件。另外,从证据失权、诉讼费功能、书面审理、虚假诉讼等方面完善配套措施,以期完善小额诉讼程序的适用条件,使小额诉讼程序真正满足人民群众的高效司法需求。
<<The current conditions for the application of the small claims procedure combine subjective and objective conditions,making some cases that should not be subject to the small claims procedure to be settled by the procedure,creating some problems. This paper analyzes the core problem of the current conditions of application-infringement of the parties’ right to choose the procedure-by analyzing the current situation of various aspects of the small claims procedure. By analyzing the conditions of its application and the relevant systems of foreign legal systems,and other procedures related to the system of horizontal comparison,combined with the summary procedure has not been able to adapt to the actual needs of the reality of the dilemma,the analysis of small proceedings meets the people’s efficient judicial needs of the important role the independent value of small proceedings-for the parties whichisan efficient procedural choice for the parties. From the perspective of respecting the parties’ right to choose the procedure,the conditions of application of the small claims procedure are improved. In addition,we will improve the supporting measures from the aspects of loss of evidence,litigation fee function,written trial,and sham litigation,in order to rebuild the conditions of application of small claims procedure,so that small claims procedure can truly meet the efficient judicial needs of the people.
<<