政策试点是中国治理实践中所特有的一种政策测试与创新机制,这种基于“试验”理念的政策制定机制,有利于控制改革风险、降低改革成本、提高改革成功率。其在经济领域治理成效显著,却时常在公共物品供给领域效果不彰。中国城市生活垃圾分类试点于2000年开始推行,2017年出台《生活垃圾分类制度实施方案》,继续以试点形式实施生活垃圾强制分类,这反而说明历行17年的生活垃圾分类试点成效甚微,尚无成熟模式可供推广。本文把中国城市生活垃圾分类作为个案,来探究政策试点的局限,认为政策试点的局限与以下三个因素有关:第一,通过行政发包的方式进行治理;第二,政策试点的供给机制与公共产品的“复杂”性质不匹配;第三,压力型体制对政策试点的影响。
<<Policy pilot is a unique policy testing and innovation mechanism in China’s governance practice. This policy making mechanism based on the concept of “experiment” is conducive to controlling reform risks,reducing reform costs and improving the success rate of reform. Its governance effect in the economic field is significant,and the problems in public goods/public services are frequent. The pilot project of classification of municipal solid waste in China was launched in 2000. The Implementation plan of classification system of municipal solid waste was issued in 2017. And the compulsory classification of municipal solid waste continued to be implemented in the form of pilot project,which shows that the pilot project of classification of municipal solid waste in the past 17 years has not achieved prospective results. This paper takes the classification of China’s municipal solid waste as an example to explore the limitations of the policy pilot,and considers that the limitations of the policy pilot are related to the following three factors:1. Governance through the way of administrative contract;2. The supply mechanism of the policy pilot does not match the “complex” nature of public products;3. The impact of the pressure system on the policy pilot.
<<