2015年《立法法》修改后将地方立法权下放给全部设区的市,该下放同时引发了“立法扩张”和“立法重复”两种完全相反的担忧。通过对样本城市市容环卫领域立法的实证分析可以得出,我国设区的市地方立法更多是在细化上位法的规定,原创性和重复性规定较少。从保守性倾向的角度出发进行分析,在法制统一、立法技术、立法权限等多重因素的影响下,设区的市采取“谨慎立法”的方式,在地方立法层面上以细化上位法为主。我国设区的市立法权的行使总体上呈现保守倾向,虽然具有一定的正面意义,但面对复杂的经济社会条件,未来应当进一步发挥人大在立法中的主导作用,减弱地方立法的保守倾向。
<<After the amendment of the Legislative Law in 2015,the local legislative power was delegated to all city divided into districts. This decentralization also raised two opposite concerns:legislative expansion and repeated legislation. Through the empirical analysis of the legislation in the field of urban sanitation in sample cities,it can be concluded that the local legislation of cities with districts in China is more to refine the provisions of the upper law,with less original and repetitive provisions. Many mechanisms have an impact on this,but from the perspective of organization,the organizational behavior mechanism and organizational incentives have an impact on the legislative power of cities with districts,and the exercise of the legislative power of cities with districts in China is generally conservative. In the future,the Local People’s Congress should play a leading role in legislation and weaken the conservative tendencies of organizations
<<Keywords: | Local LegislationCity Divided Into DistrictsSuperordinate LawThe Sociology of Organization |